Umbrella Company vs PAYE - Which Option is Best for You?

Agency PAYE, or Pay As You Earn, is the way income tax and national insurance contributions are deducted from an employee's salary. This deduction is done directly by the employer, ensuring the correct amount of tax is paid. PAYE is the main payroll option for permanent employment, and most individuals are familiar with this deduction from their paychecks. This option provides a straightforward employment structure without the need for contractors to set up their own limited company.

The income tax portion of PAYE is the tax paid on an individual's earnings, which is calculated based on the employee’s tax code and the income tax rates set by the UK government. National insurance (NI) contributions, on the other hand, are contributions made towards the UK's social security system, providing individuals with access to benefits such as the state pension, statutory sick pay, and maternity pay.

‍

In permanent employment, PAYE is the primary payroll option. Employers deduct tax and national insurance contributions before paying employees. It's crucial for both employees and employers to understand the PAYE rate, tax code, and national insurance contributions. Employees benefit from the convenience and security of regular income.

An Umbrella Company acts as an intermediary between contractors and their end clients or agencies. Essentially, it serves as the employer for contractors, handling administrative tasks such as invoicing, tax deductions, and payroll. Contractors become employees of the umbrella company, enjoying a simplified process without the administrative burdens. This setup provides them with the security of continuous employment and access to pension schemes as umbrella employees. Understanding the functions, costs, benefits and features is crucial for individuals considering contracting work, especially when comparing different umbrella companies for their specific circumstances.

Operating as intermediaries, umbrella companies pay gross pay to workers and deduct their umbrella company fees known as a margin, taxes, and national insurance contributions. Additionally, it offers internal HR support and manage employment affairs, enabling individuals to concentrate solely on their contracting career. Embracing a new contract is often facilitated by such firms, allowing contractors to seamlessly transition between contracts while maintaining compliance with employment regulations and tax obligations.

When considering the difference between umbrella company vs PAYE, it's essential to understand the implications of a new contract. A new contract can significantly impact your choice between PAYE and an umbrella company. The nature of the contract, such as its duration and terms influences the best fit option for you. Understanding how a new contract affects your employment status and tax obligations is crucial in making an informed decision between umbrella company vs PAYE.

Benefits of PAYE

PAYE offers employees a hassle-free and secure employment structure with various benefits, rights, and protections, making it an attractive option for those seeking simplicity and stability in their working arrangements.

Predictable Income: Employees under PAYE enjoy a predictable income as taxes and other deductions are already taken care of, providing financial stability.

Employment Rights: PAYE employees are entitled to various employment rights, including sick pay, holiday pay, and statutory maternity/paternity pay.

Access to Workplace Benefits: PAYE employees often have access to workplace benefits such as pension schemes, health insurance, and other perks provided by the employer.

Easier Mortgage Approval: Some lenders may find it easier to approve mortgages for PAYE employees due to the stability and predictability of their income.

Drawbacks of PAYE

Limited Tax Efficiency: PAYE may not offer the same level of tax efficiency as some other payment methods. This means that individuals may have fewer opportunities for tax planning and optimization.

No Business Expenses: PAYE employees have limited opportunities to claim business expenses compared to working through an umbrella company. This can result in higher personal costs for work-related expenses.

Fixed Employment Structure: PAYE is a fixed employment structure, and employees may have less flexibility in terms of working hours and the types of contracts they can undertake.

Temporary workers may find PAYE less favorable due to the contract duration and the potential benefits of a new contract through an umbrella company.

Benefits of Using an Umbrella Company

Administrative Simplicity: An Umbrella Company takes care of administrative tasks, including invoicing, payroll, and tax calculations, allowing contractors to focus on their work without the burden of administrative responsibilities.

Flexibility: Contractors working through an Umbrella Company enjoy flexibility in their contracts, as they are not tied to a single client or project.

Employee Benefits: Contractors under an Umbrella Company can access certain employee benefits, including holiday pay, sick pay, and pension schemes, providing a level of financial security similar to permanent employment.

Expense Claims: Contractors may be able to claim certain expenses, such as travel and accommodation costs, in compliance with HMRC regulations. This can lead to potential tax savings.

Insurance Coverage: Umbrella Companies often provide professional indemnity and public liability insurance coverage for contractors, offering protection against potential liabilities arising from their work.

IR35 Compliance: IR35 does not affect Umbrella Company contractors as they are considered employees of the umbrella organization rather than independent contractors.

Support and Guidance: Umbrella Companies offer support and guidance to contractors, addressing queries related to tax, employment, and other relevant matters, helping to handle the complexities of contracting.

Cons of Operating through an Umbrella Company

Service Fees: Umbrella Companies typically charge service fees for handling administrative tasks, including payroll and tax responsibilities. This can result in a reduction of the contractor's overall income.

Less Control Over Finances: Contractors using an Umbrella Company have less control over their financial affairs, as the company manages payroll and tax deductions.

Potential for Delays in Payment: Some contractors may experience delays in payment when using an Umbrella Company, as the payment process involves additional steps compared to direct payments.

Dependency on Umbrella Company's Compliance: If the umbrella company fails to adhere to tax and employment regulations, it may have legal and financial implications for the contractor.

‍

Before you make a choice between getting paid through an umbrella company vs PAYE, it's important to think about factors such as cost, benefits, expenses, insurance, HR support, and continuity of employment. Let's examine each of these aspects one by one to see how they compare.

Cost:

Contractors pay a fee for umbrella services. Agencies may increase assignment rates to cover their margin and various employment expenses, including the Apprenticeship Levy. It's essential to note that the umbrella margin is the only aspect that should differ between umbrella providers. Some umbrella companies may promise notably high take-home pay, often achieved by minimizing tax and National Insurance contributions (NICs). It's wise to be cautious if an offer seems too good to be true, and not fall for the tax avoidance schemes. When it comes to agency PAYE, typically, no additional fees are charged to contractors.

Employment Benefits:

In both cases, you'll become an employee of either the umbrella company or agency PAYE. Both will handle your administrative tasks and payroll and your taxes will be deducted under PAYE. The key difference is that if you opt for an umbrella company, it will be your sole employer, providing continuity of employment whether you're on a contract or not. This continuity can be beneficial when applying for a mortgage or credit. On the other hand, with agency PAYE, each new contract represents a separate employment period.

Whether you choose the umbrella or PAYE route, you'll enjoy statutory employment rights, including sick pay. Depending on the specific umbrella company, you might also have access to various medical health plans, pension schemes, and discount offers.

Expenses:

Whether you're working as an umbrella employee or an agency PAYE worker, your wages will be processed through PAYE. If you're under an umbrella company, you might qualify for specific work-related expenses after confirming your eligibility to claim 'allowable expenses.' Allowable expenses refer to costs that are "incurred wholly, exclusively, and necessarily in the performance of your duties."

Insurance:

No matter which option you pick, you'll require insurance. Reputable agencies or umbrella companies will offer the necessary coverage for your job responsibilities. Professional indemnity and public liability insurance often included in case of umbrella company. Additionally, some umbrella companies include health, life, and accident insurance without any additional charges. In case of agency PAYE, Contractors may need to arrange their own insurance coverage.

IR35:

Usually, umbrella company employees as well as agency PAYE workers are outside the scope of IR35.

HR Support:

Regardless of whether you choose an umbrella or agency PAYE, it's essential to consider potential challenging periods. Employees must be able to reach internal HR support whenever they require professional advice or guidance. This covers a range of issues, from disputes about notice or pay to concerns about unfair dismissal. The effectiveness and trustworthiness of this support differ based on the size and experience of the employer. For example, while an agency is paid by the end client, an umbrella company earns its income from the contractor (through an umbrella company’s margin). Therefore, they are better positioned to act in your best interests, especially during tough times.

Take Home Pay:

Contractors working under an umbrella company generally receive a higher take-home pay, although it could be lower or approximately the same when compared to PAYE. The difference depends on factors like the offered assignment rates, the number of days the contractor works, and the portion of income retained by the umbrella as a margin.

Is Umbrella Better than Agency PAYE?

Operating through an umbrella company is the best choice, if you:

• Work on multiple contracts simultaneously
• Seek the benefits and stability of continuous employment
• Are likely to claim travel or subsistence expenses

Agency PAYE might be a more suitable option, if you:

• Plan to contract for a short period – taking on one or two contracts (not simultaneously) before returning to permanent employment
• Prefer getting paid and having your contracts sourced by the same organization, without involving a third party.

‍

‍

Making the Right Decision

When choosing between an umbrella company vs PAYE, it's crucial to consider your long-term career goals and the potential benefits of a new contract. To ensure you make an informed choice aligned with your specific circumstances, it's advisable to consult with contractor accountants. These professionals specialize in the intricacies of tax regulations, employment structures, and financial planning for contractors, providing personalized guidance that can make a significant impact on your overall financial well-being. Remember, making the right choice now can lead to a more prosperous and stress-free contracting journey in the long run.